I'm now reverting back to the last design because Tony prefers the design. I do agree that when it was printed out the black outlines did look a lot better and stood out more. I will continue to create the island and get feedback from Tony.

This is what the design for the island itself is like so far and is almost an exact copy of the last one with a few different additions. This one is made purely using Illustrator, so it can preserve it's detail no matter how big or small it is due to it being a vector image. This is so that it is a lot easier for the web designer than dealing with a jpeg image.